JONESBORO, Ark. โ A former deputy prosecutor has sued Second Judicial District Prosecuting Attorney Sonia Hagood and Chief Deputy Prosecutor Jessica Thomason, alleging she was fired while pregnant one day after submitting maternity leave paperwork to the state.
Presley Phillips Noel filed the lawsuit Oct. 14 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas. The complaint identifies Thomason as Hagoodโs chief deputy and alleges the two discriminated against Noel because of her pregnancy, sex and anticipated leave.
According to the complaint, Noel submitted her maternity leave paperwork Jan. 8, 2026, and was fired Jan. 9. She was due to give birth in March, the lawsuit states.
Noel is represented by Sutter & Gillham. Attorney Lucien Gillham signed the complaint. Noel and her attorney, Luther Sutter, declined to comment. Hagood did not respond to a request for comment from NEA Report.
Complaint Describes Pregnancy Complications and Leave Request
Noel began working as a prosecutor in the Second Judicial District in January 2023, according to the lawsuit. She alleges she had worked more than 1,250 hours during the preceding year and met the employment requirements for leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act.
The complaint says Noel told Thomason she was pregnant and asked her to keep the information confidential. Thomason nevertheless informed Hagood, Noel alleges.
According to the complaint, Noel experienced pregnancy-related medical complications that required appointments and an emergency room visit. She says she kept Thomason informed of those complications.
Noel acknowledges asking others to cover court appearances but says those requests followed the onset of pregnancy-related medical issues and the need to attend medical appointments.
She alleges she sought approval of her maternity leave paperwork Jan. 7, submitted it to the state the next day and was terminated the following day. The complaint alleges the defendants did not follow the disciplinary process in the employee handbook.
Noel Disputes Performance Concerns
The complaint says Noel filed a charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission within 180 days of her termination.
According to Noelโs account of the defendantsโ response to that charge, they cited a May 15, 2025, evaluation that rated her 2 out of 5 in customer service, communication, accountability, professionalism, and job knowledge, skills and work product.ย The complaint says the defendants also asserted that Noel could not handle a felony docket, was insubordinate, failed to progress in training and violated office policies and directives. They described her reassignment to Mississippi County as a move to a slower docket, according to the lawsuit.
Noel disputes those explanations. She alleges the evaluation was false, was never presented to her and was created after she filed her EEOC charge. She says the only evaluation she received was a satisfactory review after her first 90 days.
She also alleges she was never counseled, warned, written up or suspended over the performance concerns described in the defendantsโ EEOC response.
The lawsuit further alleges Noel received a $32,000 merit raise in July 2025, about two months after the disputed evaluation.
According to the complaint, Noel was told in April 2025 that she would be transferred to Mississippi County to take over the Drug Task Force docket while continuing to handle the Craighead County juvenile docket. The transfer took effect in May.
Noel alleges the reassignment increased her workload from two dockets to six and required more than two hours of travel each day. She says she was not given an office and had to pay her own expenses.
Lawsuit Seeks Damages and Other Relief
The lawsuit alleges retaliation and interference under the Family and Medical Leave Act, pregnancy and sex discrimination under Title VII and the Pregnancy Discrimination Act, violations of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, and denial of equal protection under the 14th Amendment through a claim brought under 42 U.S.C. ยง 1983.
Hagood is named in both her individual and official capacities. Thomason is sued in her individual capacity.
Noel seeks damages exceeding $75,000 and other relief, including back pay, front pay or reinstatement, compensation for physical and emotional suffering, liquidated damages equal to her wage loss, punitive damages, and attorney fees and costs.
She also asks to be designated eligible for rehire, receive a positive reference and have her personnel file cleared. Other requests include training for the defendants, an apology, posting of the lawsuit and any verdict, and an order prohibiting retaliation. She has requested a jury trial.
In an Oct. 16 order, U.S. District Judge James M. Moody Jr. recused himself because Luther Sutter, an attorney with the firm representing Noel, appears on his recusal list. Moody directed the clerk to randomly reassign the case. The order did not address the merits of Noelโs allegations.
The defendants have not filed a response as of November 19, 2026.ย
Discover more from NEA Report
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






