HELENA-WEST HELENA, Ark. — A special judge found that Phillips County deliberately disguised a longtime white prosecutor’s office employee’s salary as office supplies to keep her off the county payroll and deny her retirement coverage. The county is appealing the ruling.
Retired Circuit Judge Robert Bynum Gibson Jr. ruled that Nita Murray was a county employee throughout her work for the prosecutor’s office, from Sept. 1, 1993, through her retirement Dec. 31, 2021. He ordered the county to fund retirement contributions for nearly 25 years of service that had not been credited through the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System, or APERS.
A Nov. 17 news release from Murray’s attorney, Kimberly Dale of Paragould, publicized the judge’s findings. NEA Report independently obtained the ruling from the court’s public records and confirmed that it matches the copy provided with the release. A review of subsequent filings also established that county officials filed a notice of appeal Oct. 22, a development not mentioned in the release.
The judge’s 13-page factual findings were filed Sept. 17. A final declaratory judgment and writ of mandamus, incorporating those findings, was entered Oct. 1 after a June 9 bench trial.
Salary Paid Through Her Husband
According to Gibson’s findings, Phillips County appropriated money for Murray’s salary but classified it under a budget line labeled “Supplies.” The county paid the money to her husband, Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Todd Murray, who then paid her.
Gibson found that the arrangement was an intentional effort to avoid recognizing Murray as a county employee and enrolling her in APERS because she was white.
The judge pointed to a budget appropriation of $15,125 for supplies, finding that the amount represented Murray’s pay rather than the supply needs of an office with one support staff member.
Gibson also found that Murray worked in the courthouse, had courthouse keys and was given the county employees’ manual to follow when she started. He described her performance favorably, citing testimony that she prepared cases for trial, interviewed witnesses and served as the prosecutor’s office’s point of contact for law enforcement.
Former Prosecuting Attorney Fletcher Long testified about repeated friction with the Quorum Court. Gibson cited a 2007 letter in which Long complained that the county had reduced the prosecutor’s office budget to an amount sufficient to operate for only one month.
The judge further found that Murray was denied janitorial services and that her office was allowed to become infested with mold and mildew.
Racial Evidence Disputed
Gibson relied in part on a 1999 Quorum Court resolution directing elected officials to hire Black applicants to fill vacancies. The resolution stated an objective of racial equality in the county workforce. Gibson interpreted it as excluding white applicants and found that it supported his conclusion about the county’s treatment of Murray.
The judge also relied on an earlier Equal Employment Opportunity Commission determination involving other white county employees.
County attorneys disputed that evidence. In a July 21 brief, they argued that the resolution was unsigned by the county judge and county clerk, had no legal effect and had not been shown to cause any action against Murray. They also argued that the EEOC matter involved other people and did not mention her.
Gibson rejected the argument that the county judge’s missing signature invalidated the resolution. He found that the Quorum Court had adopted it by acclamation.
Murray’s attorneys argued in their own supplemental brief that the resolution came from the county clerk’s official records and that it and the EEOC determination were relevant to motive and intent.
Although Gibson made findings of racial discrimination, the relief granted in this case concerned Murray’s employment status and retirement contributions. The judgment was not a separate award of racial discrimination damages.
Retirement Coverage Ordered
The Oct. 1 judgment determined that Murray’s salary was paid exclusively with county appropriations, that she was not an independent contractor and that she qualified as a county employee for retirement purposes.
The final judgment identifies Aug. 1, 2018, as the date Murray was added to the official county payroll. It orders retirement service credit for the earlier period beginning Sept. 1, 1993.
Gibson found that a 2017 state law specifically requiring Phillips County to pay the prosecutor’s support staff salary and benefits had taken effect a year before the county added Murray to its payroll. The county argued that it acted reasonably after Todd Murray brought the law to the Quorum Court’s attention in February 2018 and that a supplemental appropriation followed that June.
The judge also cited a Sept. 5, 2019, letter from County Judge Clark Hall acknowledging Murray’s earlier service and the county’s failure to enroll her. That acknowledgment preceded her 2021 retirement.
Under the final judgment, the county must appropriate and remit the unpaid retirement contributions, plus any penalties, interest or present-day value determined by APERS. The order requires the appropriation within 30 days of its entry, with payment to APERS to follow promptly.
The incorporated findings also state that Murray is entitled to compensation for retirement payments missed since Dec. 31, 2021, with the county providing APERS sufficient funds to accomplish that.
The judgment does not specify a total dollar amount for the retirement obligation. The records reviewed by NEA Report do not establish a final APERS calculation or confirm that the ordered payments have been made.
County Challenges Ruling
In its post-trial filings, the county argued that Murray’s lawsuit, filed April 18, 2023, was barred by a three-year statute of limitations. Its attorneys also disputed whether she had been properly appointed and argued that retirement eligibility had to be resolved through APERS and its administrative review process.
Murray’s attorneys countered that the county had a mandatory, continuing obligation to fund her position and retirement coverage. They also disputed the county’s characterization of the APERS proceedings, arguing that the agency’s board had not issued a final decision and that the employment-status question required adjudication.
Gibson rejected the county’s immunity argument, finding that recognizing Murray’s status and meeting its retirement obligations involved a mandatory duty.
“This case should have never happened. The fault lies entirely with Phillips County Quorum Court and the Phillips County Clerk,” Gibson wrote.
The final judgment also directed the county to pay Murray’s reasonable attorney fees and costs. In an Oct. 12 filing, she requested $50,575 in attorney fees and $2,727.12 in costs. Those figures are amounts requested in the petition. County attorneys opposed the request, arguing that the statutes governing declaratory judgments and writs of mandamus did not authorize the fees sought.
The Oct. 22 notice of appeal challenges the Oct. 1 judgment, an order granting attorney fees and intermediate orders affecting the case. The defendants asked that the appeal be assigned to the Arkansas Supreme Court. That request does not establish that the Supreme Court has accepted or decided the appeal.
In his September findings, Gibson said he would not grant a stay and directed any request for one to the appellate court. The notice of appeal itself does not establish that a stay was granted.
“Judge Gibson held Phillips County accountable for the treatment against a long-time employee of the prosecuting attorney’s office,” Dale said in the news release.
The case is Nita Murray v. County Judge Clark Hall et al., Phillips County Circuit Court No. 54CV-23-67.
Source records: Search ARCourts case docket, including the original complaint, Sept. 17 findings, Oct. 1 judgment, both sides’ post-trial filings, fee filings and Oct. 22 notice of appeal.
Discover more from NEA Report
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






