Craighead County

Judge Dismisses Claims Against Meta, Keeps Jonesboro Facebook Defamation Suit Open

A Craighead County judge dismissed claims against Meta and Thurstle Mullen’s counterclaim against Luther Sutter. Sutter’s defamation lawsuit over posts in a Jonesboro Facebook group remains pending.

JONESBORO, Ark. — A Craighead County judge dismissed claims against Facebook parent company Meta and denied Thurstle Mullen’s request to throw out a defamation lawsuit over posts in a Jonesboro Facebook group.

Special Circuit Judge Mackie Pierce also dismissed Mullen’s counterclaim against Arkansas attorney Luther Sutter. The court filed 11 orders Nov. 10, five days after Pierce signed them.

Judge Rejects Bid to Dismiss Defamation Suit

Sutter sued Mullen in January 2025, alleging Mullen published false statements about his legal fees and professional conduct in a Facebook group called Jonesboro’s Best Yard Sale and News Site. Sutter added former client Trista Jones as a defendant two days later, alleging she also made false statements about his fees. Sutter seeks compensatory and punitive damages for defamation and false light invasion of privacy.

Mullen denied the allegations and argued that his posts addressed matters of public concern and that Sutter was a public figure. He asked the court to dismiss the suit under Arkansas’ anti-SLAPP law, which is intended to protect speech and petitioning on matters of public concern.

Pierce found that Sutter was a private figure and that the anti-SLAPP law did not apply. He also found that Sutter had alleged enough facts for the lawsuit to proceed. Pierce declined to decide Sutter’s challenge to the constitutionality of the law.

In a separate order, Pierce denied Sutter’s request for emergency relief requiring Mullen to preserve social media records and other electronic evidence. Pierce found Sutter had failed to show a threat of irreparable harm, a likelihood of success or that the balance of equities favored granting the request.

Claims Over Facebook Account Removals Dismissed

In July 2025, Mullen alleged that Sutter helped arrange the removal of his Facebook groups and accounts. Mullen sought damages and asked the court to order Meta to restore the groups, accounts and Messenger records. NEA Report reported later that month that the original group had returned.

In a Nov. 12 message to NEA Report, Mullen said the original group was later removed again. He said he brought Meta into the case because the suspension of his Facebook account cut off his access to the posts and comments covered by Sutter’s request to preserve evidence.

Pierce found Mullen’s counterclaim against Sutter failed to allege facts that would entitle him to relief. The order grants Sutter’s July 15, 2025, motion. The docket lists an Aug. 14, 2025, joint motion from Sutter and his firm, Sutter & Gillham, with no separate ruling on that motion.

In a separate order, Pierce found that the Craighead County court lacked personal jurisdiction over Meta and that the company’s terms of service required the dispute to be heard elsewhere. He also found Mullen had failed to state a viable claim and that Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act protected Meta in this case.

Pierce denied Mullen’s request for a default judgment against Meta, citing jurisdiction, venue and defects in both attempts to serve the company.

Mullen Disputes Service Ruling

Mullen disputed Pierce’s finding in a Facebook Messenger exchange with NEA Report on Nov. 12. “I actually did serve Meta sufficiently,” he said. “There’s no law that says you have to serve only a company’s registered agent.”

Mullen acknowledged in a court filing that his first summons lacked the court clerk’s signature. He said he sent a signed replacement by certified mail addressed to Meta’s registered agent at Meta’s office in Menlo Park, California. Meta’s attorneys said the agent’s California address was in Sacramento. Pierce found the second mailing went directly to Meta.

Mullen argued that Meta missed its deadline to respond. He said the return receipt for the second mailing never came back and cited an unsigned postal printout that he said showed delivery Aug. 1, 2025. Meta said its records showed the papers reached its office Aug. 4 and that it moved to dismiss Sept. 3, 30 days later. Arkansas’ rules set requirements for addressing certified mail and documenting service before a court can enter a default judgment based on that mailing. Arkansas’ certified-mail rule

Mullen pointed to Attorney General Tim Griffin’s separate lawsuit against Meta in Polk County. The proof of service in that case says a California process server left the summons and complaint on April 25, 2023, with a security guard who appeared to be in charge at Meta’s Menlo Park office. A declaration says copies were mailed to the same office that day. The process server identified the procedure as substituted service. Polk County court records

Arkansas’ Rule 4 allows in-person service on corporate officers and other authorized recipients. It also allows out-of-state service by a method permitted where the papers are served. California law provides for substituted service on a corporation by leaving the papers with someone who appears to be in charge of the office, then mailing copies to the same address. Arkansas Rule 4 · California substituted-service law

Sutter requested a hearing on pending motions Aug. 20. The public docket listed no upcoming hearing or trial date as of Nov. 12.

Court records · Original complaint · July 2025 coverage

Original Report, Jan. 16, 2025 JONESBORO, Ark. — A conflict on Facebook has led to a lawsuit being filed by an Arkansas lawyer against a Tennessee man who runs a yard sale group for alleged defamation. Luther Sutter filed the complaint on Wednesday, Jan 15 against Thurstle Mullen in Craighead County Circuit Court, alleging defamation and other harmful statements were made in posts to a Facebook group. The lawsuit seeks compensatory and punitive damages.

See More: Sutter v Mullen

Sutter is an experienced Arkansas lawyer involved in several prominent cases in NEA, notably a fired officer’s lawsuit against Jonesboro in 2024. At one point, he seemed to be on friendly terms with Mullen, a Cordova, Tenn. resident and traveling nurse who owns the Facebook group titled: Jonesboro’s Best Yard Sale and News Site. The group was created as an online yard sale, but over time, Mullen began posting about various news stories. As he will pointedly tell anyone complaining, he owns the group and can do with it as he pleases. Most of Mullen’s posts originally targeted Heath Loggains, a JPD officer who arrested Mullen for a fight at a club in 2015. In time, his subject material has expanded to include others in law enforcement, prosecutors, and judges. He routinely offers rewards and “bounties” for information leading to the firing or prosecution of alleged corrupt officials. Mullen seemed to appreciate Sutter’s willingness to represent the underdog in fights with the government, but that all changed when Sutter began representing a Jonesboro couple, Paul and Amber Williams. Paul is also a JPD officer. For months, Mullen posted about the Williams family and their business, Lamb and Lion Childcare. Mullen alleged criminal wrongdoing. Sutter began representing the Williams couple and said he was looking to investigate the allegation.
Messages in blue are Thurstle Mullen’s. Shared by Mullen to his group.
Screenshots of conversations between Mullen and Sutter show that their relationship quickly deteriorated from there, with Mullen telling Sutter to drop his clients, and alleging that Sutter was being paid with stolen money. Mullen soon began posting publicly about Sutter, himself.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Initially, Sutter seemed to be amused and even responded with several posts of his own to the group, one of which Mullen said reached around 30,000 people before it was deleted. The amusement did not last. Tensions boiled over last week, turning amusement into anger, after Mullen replied to a comment by Sutter seeking information in a separate matter.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Sutter made good on his promise to sue Mullen by filing 16JCV-25-76 this week in Craighead County. In his complaint, Mullen is accused of publicly posting comments accusing Sutter of misrepresenting his fee contract to clients, theft by receiving, other crimes, and even an affair with client “AW.” Sutter alleges these are false and defamatory comments that were published with malice or, at the minimum, reckless disregard for the truth. “Defendant’s false and defamatory statements have caused substantial harm to Plaintiff’s personal and professional reputation, resulting in emotional distress and economic damages, including loss of business opportunities,” Sutter’s complaint alleges. The complaint alleges the causes of action are defamation and false light invasion of privacy. It seeks compensatory and punitive damages. Mullen had no comment when a reporter reached out to him. Court records do not show that he has been served. Sutter also had no comment when reached by a reporter. Read the full complaint here

UPDATE 7/17/25:

https://neareport.com/2025/07/17/facebook-group-shut-down-counterclaim-filed-in-defamation-lawsuit/

Discover more from NEA Report

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Submit a Correction

Accuracy matters. If you believe something in this story is incorrect, please tell us so our newsroom can review it.

Report an error in this story

About this story: Judge Dismisses Claims Against Meta, Keeps Jonesboro Facebook Defamation Suit Open
https://neareport.com/2025/01/16/arkansas-lawyer-suing-tennessee-nurse-who-runs-facebook-group/

Your submission is private and will not appear as a comment. The story title and link are included automatically.

2 Comments

  1. Good. He did terrible things to my aunt decades ago when he was her nurse at a local hospital.

What do you think?